Fetching data…

Explore

In theaters
Our Picks
Trending
Charts: top rated, box office, Oscars
Best of: by service and genre
Anime
What to watch tonight
How the Lantern Score works

Contact

Feedback and ideasfeedback@movielantern.com
Help and accountsupport@movielantern.com
Press and partnershipshello@movielantern.com

Credits

Lantern Score combines public ratings from IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, provided through the OMDb API (CC BY-NC 4.0) and Wikidata (CC0), with the TMDB audience rating used when none of those has a score. MovieLantern is not affiliated with or endorsed by IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes or Metacritic.

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB. Streaming availability by JustWatch.

© 2026 MovieLanternAbout Privacy Terms

Home Theaters Trending Picks Charts Saved

What should I watch tonight?

Pick a mood and get three: the masterpiece, what's trending and a recent hit.

Classics
Psychological horror
Murder mystery
Mystery / Thriller
Comedy
Action / Adventure
Romance
Traumatizing

More options: years, rating, length

Search movies, shows and anime

In theaters Our Picks Charts Trending Watchlist

Small Town Secrets

2022TV-141 seasonTV seriesStreaming now

A 34-year-old cold-case investigation into the murder of student athlete Denise Pflum in Indiana.

Documentary
Crime
History
Mystery Message

Where to watch

Country

Philo
Vice TV

Availability by JustWatch · All options on TMDB

Cast

Chad BlaesSelf. (as Det. Chad Blaes)
Craig PenningtonSelf. (as Det. Craig Pennington Ret.)
Stacy ReeseSelf. (as Det. Stacy Reese)
Gianna ToboniSelf

Details

First aired: January 11, 2022
Seasons: 1
Episodes: 3
Status: Returning Series
Network: Vice TV
Original language: English
Studios: VICE News, Vice TV

Shows like Small Town Secrets

The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare2026
Trust Me: The False Prophet2026
Death of the Pastor's Wife2026
Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda2011
Crime Scene: The Texas Killing Fields2022
Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes2022
The Yogurt Shop Murders2025
Dateline1992
I AM A KILLER2018
Cold Case Files2017
Killer Sally2022
Cold Justice2013

Shows like Small Town Secrets

The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare20266.7
Trust Me: The False Prophet20267.6
Death of the Pastor's Wife20266.7
Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda20118.9
Crime Scene: The Texas Killing Fields20226.6
Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes20227.3
The Yogurt Shop Murders20256.1
Dateline19927.4
I AM A KILLER20187.3
Cold Case Files20178.1
Killer Sally20226.7
Cold Justice20138.0

–Lantern Score
We combine IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic. One platform is enough. If none of them has a score yet, the TMDB audience rating is used.Not enough ratings yet

–User rating
The average score MovieLantern members give this title.Be the first to rate

Small Town Secrets (2022) doesn't have enough ratings for a Lantern Score yet. Stream it in the US on Philo, Vice TV .