Fetching data…
Shows like American Horror Story
If you liked American Horror Story (2011), these 24 shows have a similar feel, best Lantern Score first.
- 1
Supernatural8.6 - 2
FROM8.0 - 3
The Terror8.0 - 4
The Vampire Diaries7.7 - 5
Castle Rock7.5 - 6
Them7.5 - 7
Hammer House of Horror7.5 - 8
Masters of Horror7.4 - 9
The Haunting of Bly Manor7.4 - 10
Tales from the Darkside7.4 - 11
Motherland: Fort Salem7.3 - 12
Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities7.0 - 13
Creepshow7.0 - 14
Fear Itself6.9 - 15
Slasher6.8 - 16
The Order6.7 - 17
The Institute6.7 - 18
Lore6.6 - 19
American Horror Stories6.3 - 20
Mayfair Witches6.2 - 21
Freddy's Nightmares6.2 - 22
Sanctuary: A Witch's Tale6.2 - 23
The Hunger6.2 - 24
The Twilight Zone6.1
About this list
These shows come from TMDB's recommendations for American Horror Story, a drama and mystery series by Ryan Murphy, Brad Falchuk. Each carries its Lantern Score, IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic in one 10-point number, so the strongest matches rise to the top. The best of them right now: Supernatural (8.6), FROM (8.0), The Terror (8.0). Open any title for its full score breakdown, cast, and where to stream, rent or buy it.